What is arbitration?
Arbitration is a private alternative to court proceedings. The parties agree — usually in their contract, sometimes after a dispute arises — to refer disputes to one or more arbitrators, whose award is final and binding. In England, Wales and Northern Ireland arbitration is governed by the Arbitration Act 1996, as amended (including by the Arbitration Act 2025).
Arbitration is more formal than adjudication but more flexible than litigation. The parties can choose an arbitrator with relevant construction expertise, agree the procedure, and keep the proceedings and award confidential.
When arbitration is appropriate
- The contract contains an arbitration agreement (common in JCT, NEC and FIDIC-based contracts, depending on the options chosen)
- A final decision is needed, rather than an interim one
- Confidentiality matters to one or both parties
- The dispute is technical and benefits from an arbitrator with construction experience
- The parties are in different countries and need an award enforceable abroad
International arbitration
Arbitration awards can be recognised and enforced in more than 170 countries under the 1958 New York Convention, to which both the United Kingdom and Portugal are parties. This makes arbitration a natural choice for cross-border construction and property disputes — for example, a UK-based owner or contractor working on a project in Portugal. The law that governs the arbitration depends on its seat; an arbitration seated in Portugal, for instance, is governed by the Portuguese Voluntary Arbitration Law (Law no. 63/2011).
Challenging an award
Rights of challenge are deliberately limited. Under the Arbitration Act 1996 an award can be challenged for lack of substantive jurisdiction, for serious irregularity, or — unless excluded by agreement — appealed on a point of law with the court's permission. In practice, parties should expect the award to be final.
How Steve can help
Steve is a Fellow of the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators and an international arbitrator. He accepts appointments as sole arbitrator or as a member of a tribunal in construction, property and professional services disputes, including contractor/subcontractor and employer/contractor matters. He can also act as a party representative or adviser in arbitration proceedings where he has no independent role in the matter.
Independent appointment or party representation — never both. Steve may be appointed as the independent decision-maker in a dispute, or instructed to advise and represent one party. These are distinct roles. On any one matter he acts in one capacity only, and he will decline an instruction where there is a conflict of interest.
