What is mediation?
Mediation is a flexible, confidential process in which a neutral mediator helps the parties negotiate their own settlement. The mediator does not decide the dispute. The parties remain in control of whether to settle and on what terms; a settlement becomes legally binding once it is written down and signed.
What is said in a mediation is "without prejudice" and cannot normally be relied on in later proceedings if the dispute does not settle.
Why mediation matters in construction disputes
- It can take place at any stage — before proceedings, or alongside adjudication, arbitration or litigation
- It is usually quicker and less expensive than a contested process
- It allows commercial solutions a tribunal cannot order, such as future work or revised programmes
- It can preserve working relationships between employers, contractors and consultants
- The courts actively encourage it
The courts of England and Wales can order parties to engage in alternative dispute resolution (Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2023] EWCA Civ 1416), and an unreasonable refusal to mediate can lead to adverse costs consequences.
How Steve conducts a mediation
Steve chairs and manages the mediation, helping the parties identify the real issues, test their positions and explore options for settlement. He brings practical knowledge of how construction projects run — valuations, programmes, defects, variations — which helps conversations move beyond entrenched positions.
As mediator, Steve does not evaluate the parties' positions or advise on the merits of a settlement unless all parties expressly ask him to do so.
Steve also acts as an adviser or representative for parties attending mediations conducted by other mediators.
Independent appointment or party representation — never both. Steve may be appointed as the independent decision-maker in a dispute, or instructed to advise and represent one party. These are distinct roles. On any one matter he acts in one capacity only, and he will decline an instruction where there is a conflict of interest.
